Avatar serverside resize

General discussion of development ideas and the approaches taken in the 3.x branch of phpBB. The next feature release of phpBB 3 will be 3.3/Proteus.
Forum rules
Please do not post support questions regarding installing, updating, or upgrading phpBB 3.2.x. If you need support for phpBB 3.2.x please visit the 3.2.x Support Forum on phpbb.com.

If you have questions regarding writing extensions please post in Extension Writers Discussion to receive proper guidance from our staff and community.
User avatar
mykkal
Registered User
Posts: 8
Joined: Sun Mar 24, 2013 4:15 am
Location: Atlanta, GA
Contact:

Re: Avatar serverside resize

Post by mykkal »

t_backoff wrote:
mykkal wrote:you guys are so technical that is obvious nobody here is an expert.
Um, it's a board regarding phpBB development - what did you expect? :roll:
mykkal wrote:It is an absolute travesty that phpbb doesn't resize images. The excuses given for not doing what every other bulletin board software & CMS software already does do not remotely make sense.
If you want a kitchen sink, I hear vB and IPB include them. Just because we don't do what every other software does does not mean we are falling behind or don't care about our users. By the way, I would suggest you look up the word travesty - you are so far off base.
I'm a computer science & english major. Don't attempt to school me on context. Your not that cool :lol:

TRAVESTY -
  • A false, absurd, or distorted representation of something.
Synonyms
  • noun. parody - mockery - burlesque - skit - spoof - caricature
    verb - parody
The statements as too why this feature doesn't exist during the decade I've used this software aren't technically sound which is an exactly what a travesty is. I feel these reasons are related to expert 'arrogance' at what the social IQ of community is when relating to technical prowess. At the very least they are excuses.

Long gone are the DOS days when curiosity led the average person to learn how to re-engineer technology totally foreign to them. These days tech is more basic and standard. There are basic expectations for every category of applications. As such people usually don't resize images these days. The most heavily used sites & software in commercial application these days do it for us. Example: Flickr, instagram, twitter, photobucket, facebook, vbulletin, wordpress, etc... Many of these softwares also allow for editing of images and cropping. If we were to talk about resources that is something much more intensive than resizing animated images. Internet technologies (hardware & software) are exponentially stronger and more efficient than when phpbb was younger... My own phone has more memory and processing power than the racked server I had eight years ago. Amazingly these software applications (mostly scripts) aren't crashing from the multitudes of users utilizing as some this thread have suggested. So whats up with the technical paranoia? They have hundreds of millions of users and they work fine.

Also, and as I mentioned before, there is the culture of people today. Mobile apps, and other technologies have made many things such as remembering phone numbers things of the past. Just as the average person no longer has basic HTML skill (since the death of myspace). I haven't even memorized my own phone number since we mobilized contact lists and cell phones became "landlines". The web has matured in the same way. In that respect phpbb is caught in a self-defeating time warp. Look outside your box.

Software that doesn't meet community standards is definitely far behind. The reasons given for not integrating this function have no technical base. If they did I wouldn't have said a thing. Of course if we consider phpbb to be a 'starter drug' for forums and if we're not really concerned with it having the ability to compete with other open source software...then your on the correct path. I said something because i'm concerned.

If phpbb wants to move forward and be a 'better' board then it will need to begin to pay attention to some core details. Some functions should be created as mods. Others, like this one, have no business being left to the community when they should be core functions.

I know phpbb can tell the difference. I would do it myself but running three businesses and having retainers I have no time to do it....however were phpbb to make it a 'priority' for future versions i'm sure someone would.

As for suggesting other boards...thats actually offensive. :oops: What i'm reading is that you want praise for the features we all like but want to tell your community to kick rocks when we consistently ask for a feature that we've deemed a 'need'. Thats how social community's fail. Pay attention to your demographic base. We aren't stupid. 8-)

Lastly, I believe the entire internet has a responsibility to support free and advanced ways of syndicating information. If phpbb really wants to build communities the average person can use to disseminate & digest information...I think it should begin an internal culture change. Simple services like Twitter and MediaWiki are getting it right. They have enough detail under the hood that average citizens have communicated and built self contained communities globally. Your neighbor can compete with large media networks that once controlled the flow of information. phpbb has the ability to do that on the forum side if they really want. But this culture of deciding what is best over the communities demands has to stop. It violates every rule of progression that is civilized. No business or society can do such things without eventual implosion.
I love technology to the point my home runs on Windows.
Favorite sites I've built. http://MyModelTalk.com http://Rashaentertainment.com

User avatar
Marc
Development Team Leader
Development Team Leader
Posts: 159
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2010 11:36 am
Location: Munich, Germany

Re: Avatar serverside resize

Post by Marc »

It's weird that you think that we are totally ignoring the users' requests when there is already a ticket for that since November:
http://tracker.phpbb.com/browse/PHPBB3-11207

This has been held back due to major changes in the avatar system.

User avatar
mykkal
Registered User
Posts: 8
Joined: Sun Mar 24, 2013 4:15 am
Location: Atlanta, GA
Contact:

Re: Avatar serverside resize

Post by mykkal »

Then that should have been stated instead of the negative remarks. It was unnecessary. I haven't seen anything like that in this thread.

There's nothing weird about it.
I love technology to the point my home runs on Windows.
Favorite sites I've built. http://MyModelTalk.com http://Rashaentertainment.com

User avatar
mykkal
Registered User
Posts: 8
Joined: Sun Mar 24, 2013 4:15 am
Location: Atlanta, GA
Contact:

Re: Avatar serverside resize

Post by mykkal »

Also one would think that a moderator would be aware of things like this and a simple 'registered' user like myself would not. This is the culture of phpbb that i'm talking about.

It needs to change and you guys need to learn how to communicate better.
I love technology to the point my home runs on Windows.
Favorite sites I've built. http://MyModelTalk.com http://Rashaentertainment.com

User avatar
tbackoff
Registered User
Posts: 180
Joined: Sat Jun 12, 2010 3:25 am

Re: Avatar serverside resize

Post by tbackoff »

mykkal wrote:As for suggesting other boards...thats actually offensive. :oops:
Whoa, let's cool it here. I never said "pack your bags and leave". I was just making a point that phpBB doesn't just add functionality because so-and-so did.
mykkal wrote:What i'm reading is that you want praise for the features we all like but want to tell your community to kick rocks when we consistently ask for a feature that we've deemed a 'need'. Thats how social community's fail. Pay attention to your demographic base. We aren't stupid. 8-)
I never said you (or anyone else) were stupid. I also never said that this functionality was bloat or un-needed (again, more geared at the " not doing what every other bulletin board software & CMS software already does" comment you made).
mykkal wrote:Also one would think that a moderator would be aware of things like this and a simple 'registered' user like myself would not.
I don't follow the tracker (although I admit, if I want to be more involved in development, I probably should). It's not a requirement for moderators though.

Friends? :P

User avatar
mykkal
Registered User
Posts: 8
Joined: Sun Mar 24, 2013 4:15 am
Location: Atlanta, GA
Contact:

Re: Avatar serverside resize

Post by mykkal »

Friends. I only meant to contribute.
I love technology to the point my home runs on Windows.
Favorite sites I've built. http://MyModelTalk.com http://Rashaentertainment.com

Post Reply